Head to head

PING G440 vs TaylorMade Qi irons

Choose the G440 if a slice is part of your miss; choose the Qi if you want a slightly stronger set or need a ladies flex. For a slow swing, look at the G440 HL and the Qi HL.

G440 $999Qi $899.99, each with its shop and checked date

Both are game improvement irons, and the G440 scores a little higher here, 3.5 of 5 against 3. PING prints 4.6 mm of offset at the G440's 7-iron, which gives the face more time to square up; TaylorMade prints none for the Qi, but says it built the Qi's face against the right miss that most game improvement irons favour, and its chart rates the Qi High for forgiveness. The Qi's lofts are a degree or so stronger from the 5- to the 8-iron (a 28° 7-iron against 29°); the two meet at a 37° 9-iron, and the Qi's PW is a degree weaker, 43° against 42°. PING made the G440's 4-, 5- and 6-irons longer than the G430's for a higher launch. The G440 is built by the club and also comes in extra stiff; the Qi comes in a ladies flex.

  1. Forgiveness 3.5 out of 5

    PING G440

    $999 at Golf Discount7 irons (4-PW) · checked 2 Nov

    Used from $574.99 at 2nd Swing Golf6 clubs (6-GW), steel, stiff flex, average condition · checked 31 Oct

  2. Forgiveness 3.0 out of 5

    TaylorMade Qi

    $899.99 at TaylorMade7 irons · checked 2 Nov

    Used from $512.99 at 2nd Swing Golf5 clubs (6-PW), steel, stiff flex, average condition · checked 31 Oct

PING G440

7-iron loft 29°; offset 4.6 mm; sole width not published.

TaylorMade Qi

7-iron loft 28°; offset not published in mm; sole width not published.

Drawn to the same scale from each maker's loft, offset and sole: drawings, not photos. A dashed line marks a dimension the maker does not publish.
  1. Side view to scale: 4.6 mm offset

    Forgiveness 3.5 out of 5

    PING G440

    A forgiving game improvement iron with what PING calls a players-style look: 4.6 mm of offset and a 29° 7-iron. For a slow swing, the G440 HL is the same head in a lighter build.

    $999 at Golf Discount7 irons (4-PW) · checked 2 Nov

    Used from $574.99 at 2nd Swing Golf6 clubs (6-GW), steel, stiff flex, average condition · checked 31 Oct

    Offset
    4.6 mm
    Sole
    Not published
    7-iron loft
    29°
    Hand
    Left or right
    Flex
    Senior to extra stiff

    Fits golfers who make decent contact and want help on the misses with a slimmer head.

    Choose the G740 instead if thin and heavy strikes are your main miss: it has the bigger, wider-soled head. For a lighter build that suits a slower swing, look at the G440 HL.

  2. Side view, drawn to scale

    Forgiveness 3.0 out of 5

    TaylorMade Qi

    TaylorMade's game improvement iron before the Qi Max, with the same 28° 7-iron. TaylorMade says it built the face against the right miss that most game improvement irons favour, and its own chart rates its forgiveness High, as it rates the Qi Max's.

    $899.99 at TaylorMade7 irons · checked 2 Nov

    Used from $512.99 at 2nd Swing Golf5 clubs (6-PW), steel, stiff flex, average condition · checked 31 Oct

    Offset
    Not published
    Sole
    Not published
    7-iron loft
    28°
    Hand
    Left or right
    Flex
    Ladies to stiff

    Fits golfers who make decent contact and want help on the misses with a slimmer head.

    Choose the Qi Max HL instead if you want a higher flight from a slower swing: TaylorMade rates it Highest for forgiveness.

Side by side

PING G440 vs TaylorMade Qi irons
DetailG440Qi
Forgiveness score3.5 of 53.0 of 5
ClassGame improvementGame improvement
7-iron loft29°28°
Offset, 7-iron4.6 mm–
Solenot publishednot published
FlexesA · R · S · XL · A · R · S
HandsRH · LHRH · LH

Loft, club by club

As each maker publishes it. A stronger loft flies lower and longer; it is not more forgiveness.

Lofts by club
ClubG440Qi
4-iron19°18.5°
5-iron22°21°
6-iron25.5°24°
7-iron29°28°
8-iron33°32°
9-iron37°37°
PW42°43°
WedgesUW 47°
52°
56°
AW 48°
SW 54°
LW 59°

See every specification side by side, and add a third club if you like.